Carrie Underwood Awards
- 2008: Academy of Country Music: Top Female Vocalist
- 2008: CMA: Female Vocalist of the Year
- 2008: Grammy: Best Country Song
- 2008: Grammy: Best Female Country Vocal Performance
- 2007: CMA: Female Vocalist of the Year
- 2007: CMA: Single of the Year
- 2007: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year
- 2007: CMT Music Awards: Video Director of the Year
- 2007: CMT Music Awards: Video of the Year
- 2007: Grammy: Best Country Song
- 2007: Grammy: Best Female Country Vocal Performance
- 2006: Academy of Country Music: Album of the Year
- 2006: Academy of Country Music: Single of the Year
- 2006: Academy of Country Music: Top Female Vocalist
- 2006: Academy of Country Music: Top New Female Vocalist
- 2006: CMA: Female Vocalist of the Year
- 2006: CMA: Horizon Award
- 2006: CMT Music Awards: Breakthrough Video of the Year
- 2006: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year